Universe/Something comically comes out of Nothing

This is presented as a conversation or discussion between the two friends Kri and Udh:

Kri: Hey Udh, Universe came from Nothing.

Udh: No, it did not.

Udh: Universe came from something, something always comes from something.

Kri: Where did that something, from which Universe came, come into being then?

Udh: Well, even that something came from something else.

Kri: And where did that come from?

Udh: From something else.

Kri: So, it all goes back forever?

Udh: Yes. But, it does not necessarily have to be an infinite series of unique events/things. It can even be finite number of unique events or something and be cyclic, you know.

Kri: Hmm…. But isn’t universe this whole everything in itself?

Isn’t that every “something”, be it in infinite numbers or finite number of them, all included in the thing called the “Universe”?

Doesn’t Universe, by definition, contain all of those somethings?

Udh: Hmm…. Yes.

Kri: So, the universe or call it everything or call it all of or whole of the something(s), be it infinite in number or finite in number, came from Nothing?

Udh: No, they’re eternal, they don’t come from anything, or rather they come from themselves.

Kri: Exactly my point you see, they come from nothing. They don’t come from anything, means they come from Not a thing, i.e. they come from Nothing.

Udh: No, they come from themselves, they don’t come from nothing.

Kri: For it to come out of itself, it must pre-exist itself, which sounds like a contradiction. But even ignoring that, say it comes out of itself. Let’s agree on that. But then coming out of itself to itself is not “coming out” at all. Also not coming out is “not coming out”, not coming out is not “coming out”.

If that coming out is not coming out, then that’s a contradiction as well.

Udh: Oh!, I guess so.

Kri: So, the universe or all of everything didn’t come out of itself as well, and didn’t come out of anything.

Udh: Yes, I think that’s true.

Kri: So, the universe came out of, NOTHING.

Kri: In other words, Universe came out of NOTHING. Well, it’s not really, “in other words”, but what I meant was in “other tone”.

Udh: But, Universe is a necessary thing, it exists simply because it’s necessary.

Kri: Again my point, it is necessary so it wouldn’t have come from anything else, and it cannot come from itself, so in general, it cannot come from anything, so it just ‘is’. And that in other words again means, Universe came from NOTHING, not-a-thing.

Udh: Wha….What! Hmm…. I think so, what?, Damn!   


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

On the nature of Nature

Image
  ON THE NATURE OF NATURE We have been discussing about the design and developing new and clearer theories that we think can precisely define the nature of nature. We have been trying to explain her grand creation on the basis of the observations or events that take place around us. We are doing so from the beginning of our human history. We observe, explain, predict and test. The explanation sometime and in some condition agrees and sometime in some other condition disagrees or fails. But still we are confident that we can describe nature of nature in a way that is certain by making a realization that our views still lack something. Today we are known about many subjects of nature but still we believe there is a perfect model that perfectly explains the design of nature. Is keeping such belief a mistake? Nature on the fundamental level has no law. Nature demands not to act in any certain perfect way or pattern. There is no any limitation to how nature can act. Nature is absolutely...
Read more

Absolutism – The search for the Absolute

I often ask myself, what? why?, I can find many hows, so hows are not primary for me. It is the easiest among them. No matter what the answer is, or how many answers there are, it all fades to insignificance. What does not fade in insignificance is the question itself. It stands strong and proud as ever. Trying to find the answer, the search has always been for an answer. The answer that is supposedly nothing but that is expected to be the representation of the Absolute – that which is invariant, immortal, Permanent. But everything, every answer fades and is temporary, goes extinct, vanishes into nothing, into insignificance. The ‘answer’ that was supposed to express and teach immortality, itself fades to non-existence, itself consumed by death so to speak. Never ever came to realization, that the Question that has been staring at me, and that I’ve been staring at, is the one that has never abandoned me. It has always stood there facing the answer that were supposed to destroy it, and,...
Read more

NOTHING = EVERYTHING

Image
What is Everything? Let me define everything as such: Everything is that which ‘exists’. It is that which is ‘real’. It is the ‘state’. Existence is experience, it is measure, it is ‘state’. So, for state A, A exists. For state B, state B exists, and so on. Now, does state B and/or state C and/or any state ‘not A’, exist for A? The answer is that for any state A, the state, any state, ‘not A’ or ‘A complement’, is absolutely undefined. One cannot say that “B exists for A”, one cannot say “B doesn’t exist for A”. So for state A, state A is everything, it is the universe for itself. For state B, state B is everything/universe, and so on. So, ‘everything’ is not absolute, it’s relative. Now, of course, for state A, state A is absolute, it is ‘absolute everything’ for itself. For B, B is ‘absolute everything’, and so on. The thing that needs to pointed out is that, any state is quantized. State is a quantized entity. It cannot be reduced to any smaller parts. It is the smallest entity, and...
Read more